15 Comments
Jun 15, 2023Liked by Caroline Chambers

I love this recipe. I keep burning the seasoning on the steak. Do I have the heat too high?

Expand full comment
Apr 24, 2023Liked by Caroline Chambers

Dug into the archives for this one to cook up a thick tenderloin and it came out to perfection!!

Expand full comment

This was great- steak came out perfectly. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Jan 5, 2021Liked by Caroline Chambers

Can you sub sweet potatoes in this recipe??

Expand full comment

How cold do the potatoes have to be once they go in the fridge? Like 10 min enough or completely cool! So glad I subscribed! Xo a fellow boarding school alum

Expand full comment

This was a *tasty* vday meal (even though I dropped my steak on the ground as I was pouring the juices on the taters)

Expand full comment

I’ve never cooked a steak well before…. This was delicious! The directions were easy to follow and spelled everything out so I felt comfortable cooking something I have zero experience with.

Expand full comment

I keep coming back for this recipe, it is just so good! Tonight we did venison backstraps that my husband cut about 2.5 inches wide and an inch thick so I only did 2 minutes per side. I also threw sliced mushrooms in on top of the potatoes! Every time we feel like we’re at a fancy restaurant and not just in our living room watching Netflix and eating an adult dinner after our kids are in bed 😂.

Expand full comment

Made this last night. It was my first time purchasing and cooking steak. The whole family LOVED it. I did it! Thank you!

Expand full comment